Town Topics September 15, 2004 Legal Forum: "Caring
for Yourself and Your Family, A Short Guide to Family and Medical Leave"
by
Edward M. Konin
Reprinted with permision of the Town Topics.
Good management and good job performance
require hard work and attention to detail. They
also require employers and employees to have
adequate knowledge about when it’s time to
take a break to care for themselves and their
families. Even though there is no legal requirement
that businesses grant health insurance
coverage or certain other benefits that most of
us take for granted, federal and state laws
clearly require covered employers (those with
50 or more employees) to provide a fairly substantial
amount of leave time (up to 12 weeks)
to allow employees to take care of serious medical
conditions, care for ailing family members
and, whether the employee is male or female, to
care for a newborn child or a child placed with
an employee’s family for adoption or foster
care.
Medical and family issues are very personal
and individualized. Therefore, even the detailed
federal and state rules, and the comprehensive
personnel policy manuals prepared by most
businesses cannot deal fully with every situation.
The result is that each request for medical
or family leave is usually evaluated on a caseby-
case basis.
In view of the complex nature of family and
medical leave issues, the purpose here is to
present some of the more important factors of
which employers and employees should be
aware, and to point out areas requiring close
attention by those requesting leave and those
who evaluate those requests. The following
specific areas should always be carefully
reviewed as they apply to any given leave
request:
1. Employers have the right to determine if
leave will be paid, unpaid, or a combination
of both; however, the policy must be the
same as that which is applied to other types
of leave.
2. Leave should be requested at least 30 days
before the leave is to begin, although this is
very often not possible. Notice of intent to
return to work should also be provided.
3. Employers have the right to request medical
certification sufficient to demonstrate the
need for the leave, whether it is for the
employee or family member. All illnesses do
not necessarily qualify as serious health conditions
resulting in entitlement to family or
medical leave.
4. An employer has the right to require medical
certification of fitness to return to work upon
the expiration of a leave of absence. If the
employee’s medical condition precludes
return to work, the employee can be terminated
if all other time off has been exhausted.
5. An employer has the right to eliminate the
position of an employee who is on medical
or family leave, including pregnancy and
childbirth, provided it is part of a valid
reduction in force.
6. Leave may be denied when requested by certain
key employees, if the employer reasonably
determines that granting it will cause “substantial and grievous economic injury”
to the employer’s business.
7. Upon return from leave, an employee is entitled
to reinstatement to the position held
when the leave began or an equivalent position
with equivalent seniority, status, benefits
and pay.
8. The method of calculation of the amount of
leave entitlement should be fully understood
by the employer and employee.
9. Any expectations the employer has of the
employee during the leave should be clearly
spelled out in company policies.
The rights granted by the federal and state
family and medical leave laws are significant;
however, they can be properly implemented
only if employers and employees have an adequate
understanding of their benefits and limitations,
and work in good faith to apply the laws
in a fair and reasonable manner.