Search Site
Menu
COAH Update September 2013
On September 26, 2013, the New Jersey Supreme Court issued its long awaited decision on the validity of the COAH (Council on Affordable Housing) Third Round Rules. The key issue was whether or not the new proposed “growth share” approach to defining a municipal affordable housing obligation was constitutional. In a 3-2 decision, the Court held that the “growth share ” methodology was not permitted under the current provisions of the New Jersey Fair Housing Act of 1985. The Court found that since the new formula was based on housing needs from statewide (not regional) data for projected employment and residential growth, it would not be permitted under the Act. The Court found that the “growth share” approach was not based on COAH adopted region-specific data and was not structured to establish a firm obligation for each municipality in respect to prospective affordable housing needs. The court, however, did not hold the growth share methodology unconstitutional.
 
The Court sent the matter back to COAH with instructions to come up with a new set of substantive rules within the next five months using the Round One and Round Two methodology. The two Justices who dissented felt that the “growth share” approach was reasonable and realistic and permitted by the Act. Both the majority and minority challenged the New Jersey Legislature to weigh in on the issue if it wanted to permit a different methodology to calculate the Third Round obligations. The decision is now three weeks old and there is still no word from COAH. It is not likely COAH will meet the five month deadline since it has only met twice in the last two years. The Administration still wants to abolish the Council. Doing so would create a staggering task by attempting to apply the old methodology to the current and future municipal obligation.
 
The Third Round was to have started in 1999. Assuming the new rules take effect in 2014, COAH has a fifteen-year catch up period, together with a requirement to establish the municipal obligations for the next ten years. Whatever methodology ends up being adopted will dictate each municipality’s affordable housing obligations for twenty-five years. The previous cycles assigned obligations for six year periods, so one can only imagine what the numbers are going to look like for a quarter of a century of housing obligations. Clearly this calls for a legislative solution.
 
Firm Director Ed Schmierer serves on the New Jersey State League of Municipalities COAH Committee and has already started working with the League on a legislative solution. Many communities were hoping that this most recent Supreme Court decision would clarify matters, but unfortunately, just the opposite has occurred. Affordable housing obligations for municipalities still remain very much up in the air and will likely remain in limbo for the foreseeable future.
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Zuckerman Joins Firm

    Elizabeth Zuckerman has been named Of Counsel to the Princeton law firm, Mason, Griffin & Pierson, P.C, and will lead its Employment Law section. Ms. Zuckerman received a J.D. from the University of California at Davis School of Law where she served as Executive Editor for the Law Review. In 1997, Ms. Zuckerman co-founded the employment law firm of Zuckerman & Fisher, LLC, focusing her practice on employee rights. Ms. Zuckerman is admitted to practice law in New Jersey, the Third Circuit, and the U.S. Supreme Court. She will continue to practice in the areas of employment law, employee rights and appellate practice. Ms. Zuckerman serves on the Executive Committee of the New Jersey chapter of the National Employment Lawyers Association and is a member of the New Jersey State and American Bar Associations.

  • MG&P Celebrates 65th Anniversary

    Mason, Griffin & Pierson is celebrating its sixty-fifth anniversary. Since its founding in 1955, the firm has evolved from a two-man general practice partnership to a mid-size professional corporation which continues a general practice but has developed specific areas of concentration. The firm has been an integral part of central New Jersey over the past sixty-five years. The firm's first municipal client, Princeton, remains a client today, along with other municipalities and governing bodies in Mercer, Somerset, Middlesex, Hunterdon, Camden and Gloucester counties. Two of the firm's attorneys have served as President of the Mercer County Bar Association and, in 2001, the firm received the Community Partner Award from Mercer County Bar Foundation. Four of the firm's attorneys have been honored with the Fred G. Stickel Award for Excellence in Municipal Law and Service to the Legal Profession.

  • Princeton Adult Education Class - Know Your Rights as an Employee

    Elizabeth Zuckerman will be an instructor for the Princeton Adult Education course, Know Your Rights as an Employee. The 3-session course starts on February 11 and will explore topics including sexual harassment, discrimination, medical marijuana in the workplace, whistle-blower claims, NJ’s newly enacted Wage Theft Act, Federal and State family leave acts, and other laws that protect employees. Ms. Zuckerman has been practicing employment law for thirty years in Princeton and serves on the Executive Committee of the New Jersey chapter of the National Employment Lawyers Association. For more information visit .princetonadultschool.org.

  • Welcome New Municipal Clients

    MG&P starts the new year with new municipal clients. Kevin Van Hise has been appointed as the attorney for the West Amwell Township Zoning Board of Adjustment and Edwin Schmierer was recently retained by the Borough of Elmwood to serve as Special Counsel.

  • New Jersey Supreme Court Case

    Elizabeth Zuckerman will be arguing in the NJ Supreme Court on February 3rd, in the case of Wild v. Carriage Funeral Holdings, Inc. The case involves the issue of whether an employee who uses medical marijuana can be terminated for failing a drug test. Ms. Zuckerman will be arguing on behalf of Amicus NELA-NJ.